| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
|
|
|
|||||||
|
|||||||||
Department of Physiology and Biophysics, Hotchkiss Brain Institute, University of Calgary, Calgary, Canada
ABSTRACT I. INTRODUCTION: IDIOPATHIC GENERALIZED EPILEPSIES A. Classification of Seizures and Epilepsies B. Features of Idiopathic Generalized Epilepsy II. MOLECULAR PHYSIOLOGY OF VOLTAGE-GATED CALCIUM CHANNELS AND ASSOCIATED ANCILLARY SUBUNITS A. Subtypes and Physiological Roles of Voltage-Gated Calcium Channels B. Molecular Structure of Voltage-Gated Calcium Channels C. Structural Basis of Calcium Channel Function D. Ancillary Subunits of Calcium Channels III. VOLTAGE-GATED CALCIUM CHANNELS AND ANCILLARY SUBUNITS IN IDIOPATHIC GENERALIZED EPILEPSY A. T-Type Calcium Channels and Spike-Wave Seizures 1. T-type channel physiology 2. T-type calcium channel distribution 3. T-type channels and the thalamocortical network 3. Genetic animal models 4. T-type channel mutations in epileptic patients B. P/Q-Type Channel Defects and Spike-Wave Seizure Disorders 1. Cav2.1 channels and murine models of absence epilepsy 2. Cav2.1 channelopathies in humans C. Involvement of Ancillary Subunits of Voltage-Gated Calcium Channels in Seizure Disorders D. Antiepileptic Drugs and Calcium Channel Pharmacology IV. CONCLUSIONS NOTE ADDED IN PROOF GRANTS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS REFERENCES
 |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
 Top NextReferences |
|---|
|
I. INTRODUCTION: IDIOPATHIC GENERALIZED EPILEPSIES |
|---|
|
TopPreviousNextReferences |
|---|
A. Classification of Seizures and Epilepsies
From a clinical perspective, seizures can be classified into two broad categories (107). Focal (or partial) seizures are localized to one hemisphere and involve only a small brain region such as an area within the motor cortex that can result in motor seizures. Partial epileptic seizures may also arise from focal brain lesions caused, for example, by traumatic brain injury (116). However, it is now known that certain focal epilepsies can have a genetic origin (287). The second category comprises generalized seizures, which are characterized by virtually simultaneous onset of seizure activity over both brain hemispheres as seen using field potential recordings (Fig. 1). These generalized epileptic syndromes can further be classified as either symptomatic or idiopathic. Symptomatic generalized epilepsy is thought to be caused by identifiable factors such as anoxia and infection, which can result in widespread brain damage. In contrast, idiopathic generalized epilepsies have no clear etiology and may be at least partly caused by defects at the genetic level (20, 202). Data gathered from several cohort studies suggest that the frequency of idiopathic generalized epilepsies in the general epilepsy population is between 15 and 20% (reviewed in Ref. 130). As outlined above, although epileptic disorders span a continuum of conditions, we focus here predominantly on idiopathic generalized epilepsies to highlight recent developments implicating the involvement of voltage-gated calcium channels in this spectrum of epilepsy disorders.
|
3–4 Hz and are maximal over frontal midline regions with minimal involvement of posterior brain regions (85, 122, 234). In generalized epilepsy, SWDs are principally mediated by interactions between thalamic and cortical networks (19) and are known to involve the activity of voltage-gated calcium channels. It must be noted that although absence seizures are always associated with SWDs, the converse is not true as SWDs are observed in other forms of epilepsy (85). This is a relevant point when considering subsequent discussion on models of spike-wave epilepsy.
|
Patients affected by idiopathic generalized epilepsy commonly present with their first seizure between the ages of 3 and 16 (107); however, adult onset has also been reported (187). Patients with idiopathic epilepsy syndromes exhibit no underlying structural or brain lesions when assayed by radiological imaging and are otherwise neurologically normal (84, 107). In the case where absence seizures are the predominant epileptic seizure type (84), childhood absence epilepsy and juvenile absence epilepsy encompass the two main idiopathic epilepsy subtypes. Patients with childhood absence epilepsy are typically neurologically normal. On the other hand, juvenile absence epilepsy patients often have intellectual impairment and they have atypical absence seizures, characterized by a longer duration, less abrupt onset, loss of postural tone, and often the co-occurrence of other seizure types (Table 1). Two other idiopathic generalized epilepsy seizure types, juvenile myoclonic epilepsy and idiopathic generalized epilepsy with tonic-clonic seizures alone (4) (Table 1), are recognized by the international classification (3). Specific diagnosis of different idiopathic generalized epilepsy types occurs best when both clinical and EEG data are available. It is interesting to note that generalized tonic-clonic seizures in idiopathic generalized epilepsy usually occur after awakening, particularly from a brief period of sleep when preceded by sleep deprivation. This relation is particularly clear in patients with juvenile myoclonic epilepsy and implicates the thalamocortical network, which is known to be involved in both sleep rhythm and SWD generation.
Of the absence-type idiopathic generalized epilepsy disorders, childhood absence epilepsy is perhaps the one that has been most extensively studied at the genetic level. Patients with childhood absence epilepsy can have a family history of epilepsy that is inherited in an autosomal dominant manner, with concordances of up to 85% reported in monozygotic twins (15). However, genetic studies have also identified individuals with mutant genes who do not exhibit the epileptic phenotype (244). Moreover, the precise identification of gene loci is complicated by the presence of a large number of genetic polymorphisms in the childhood absence epilepsy population (241). Therefore, it is not entirely clear what the relative contributions of external or endogenous factors (such as involvement of multiple genes) are in bringing about the spectrum of epileptic seizure types observed in idiopathic generalized epilepsies. Nonetheless, there is substantial evidence implicating a genetic component in idiopathic generalized epilepsy, and in particular in absence-type seizure disorders (120). Genetic association studies have identified mutations in a number of different types of voltage- and ligand-gated ion channels, including GABAA receptors, as well as voltage-dependent sodium, potassium, and chloride channels, resulting in either a gain or loss of function (102, 201, 285) (see Table 2).
|
|
II. MOLECULAR PHYSIOLOGY OF VOLTAGE-GATED CALCIUM CHANNELS AND ASSOCIATED ANCILLARY SUBUNITS |
|---|
|
TopPreviousNextReferences |
|---|
Voltage-gated calcium channels are key mediators of calcium entry into neurons in response to membrane depolarization. Calcium influx via these channels mediates a number of essential neuronal responses, such as the activation of calcium-dependent enzymes, gene expression (72, 93, 273), the release of neurotransmitters from presynaptic sites (247, 258, 302), and the regulation of neuronal excitability (217). The nervous system expresses a number of different calcium channels with unique cellular and subcellular distributions and specific physiological functions. They have been classified into two major categories (41): low voltage-activated (LVA) calcium channels (i.e., T-type channels) and high voltage-activated (HVA) channels, although this classification should not be applied rigidly, as some of the HVA channel subtypes can, under certain circumstances, be activated at relatively negative voltages (308). As outlined in greater detail below, LVA channels are activated by small depolarizations near typical neuronal resting membrane potentials and are key contributors to neuronal excitability. Their functional identification is aided by their sensitivities to blockers such as nickel ions (95, 161), mibefradil (190), and the scorpion venom-derived peptide kurtoxin (49, 250); however, the above blockers cannot be considered as truly selective for T-type channels. HVA channels require larger membrane depolarizations to open and can be further subdivided, based on pharmacological and biophysical characteristics, into L-, N-, R-, P-, and Q-types. L-type channels are slow to activate and inactivate with barium as the charge carrier and are defined by their sensitivities to dihydropyridine agonists and antagonists (95). They are typically found on cell bodies where they participate, among other functions, in the activation of calcium-dependent enzymes and in calcium-dependent gene transcription events (8, 72, 298). N-type channels produce inactivating currents that are selectively and potently inhibited by 
-conotoxins GVIA and MVIIA, two peptides isolated from fish-hunting marine snails (2, 91, 212, 230). P- and Q-type channels are identified by their differential sensitivities to the American funnel web spider toxin -agatoxin IVA (2), and like N-type channels, they are concentrated at presynaptic nerve terminals where they are linked to the release of neurotransmitters (300, 301). In the context of neurotransmitter release, N-type and P/Q-type channels do not appear to be created equally, as N-type channels tend to support inhibitory neurotransmission, whereas the P/Q-type channels have more frequently been linked to the release of excitatory neurotransmitters but can also support inhibitory release (32, 33, 76, 163, 225). R-type channels were originally termed as such because of their resistance to the above blockers (229). These channels are rapidly inactivating and activate at somewhat more hyperpolarized potentials compared with the other HVA calcium channel subtypes (257). They can potently, albeit not totally selectively, be inhibited by SNX-482, a peptide toxin isolated from tarantula venom (23, 206). R-type channels are distributed in proximal dendrites and presynaptic nerve termini (288, 311, 316). Their precise physiological function remains enigmatic; however, there is evidence that these channels underlie carbachol-dependent plateau potentials in hippocampal CA1 neurons (152) and may mediate neurotransmitter release at select synapses (296).
B. Molecular Structure of Voltage-Gated Calcium Channels
HVA calcium channels are heteromultimers that are formed through association of 
1-, 
-, 2-
-, and 
-subunits (Fig. 2). In contrast, LVA channels may contain only the 1-subunit; however, this remains an area of controversy. While effects of ancillary subunit coexpression on T-type channel function have been reported in certain expression systems (75, 79, 121), antisense knockdown of calcium channel -subunits in neurons does not appear to affect T-type channel function (155, 169). Moreover, a biochemical association between T-type channel 1- and ancillary subunits has not been demonstrated (79).
|
1-subunit, which contains the key structural moieties that are required for a functional calcium channel, and which is the sole determinant of the calcium channel subtype. To date, nine different types of neuronal calcium channel 1-subunits have been identified and shown to fall into three major classes: Cav1, Cav2, and Cav3 (Fig. 2). The Cav1 family encodes different isoforms of L-type channels (149, 193, 197, 282, 304). Among the Cav2 family, alternate splice isoforms of Cav2.1 encode P- and Q-type channels (22), Cav2.2 represents N-type channels (80), and Cav2.3 corresponds to R-type channels (229, 257, 305) (for review, see Ref. 254). Finally, the Cav3 family represents three different types of T-type channels (i.e., Cav3.1, Cav3.2, and Cav3.3) with distinct kinetic properties (43, 56, 145, 160, 194, 198, 199, 216). These different types of calcium channel 1-subunits support specific physiological functions, as evident from findings obtained from calcium channel knockout mice (Table 3), and by studying genetic abnormalities in calcium channels in disease states (for review, see Ref. 219).
|
To provide a context for the effects of mutations in calcium channel genes that have been linked to the etiologies of neurological disorders such as epilepsy, we will briefly touch on the structural determinants of calcium channel function. The 1-subunits are comprised of four major transmembrane domains that are structurally homologous to those found in voltage-gated sodium and potassium channels (reviewed in Refs. 39, 40; see Fig. 2). Each domain consists of six transmembrane helices, with intracellularly localized NH2 and COOH termini. The fourth membrane-spanning -helix (S4 segment) contains positively charged arginine and lysine residues every three to four amino acids. Mutagenesis and crystallization studies involving potassium channels have confirmed early suggestions that this region forms the voltage sensor (38), a structural element that translocates within the membrane in response to changing membrane potential (77, 132, 176) and mediates channel opening. The reentrant P-loops between S5 and S6 segments are believed to line the pore of the channel to allow for the passage of permeant ions. The P-loops each contain a critical glutamic acid residue (4 in total) that together form a ring of negative charge and allow for selectivity of divalent cations over monovalent ions (82, 307, 309). However, other amino acid residues in the outer vestibule of the pore are likely to contribute to ion permeation and selectivity (92, 242). The 1-subunits also contain the key structural elements that allow the channel to inactivate upon prolonged membrane depolarization. Voltage-dependent inactivation, a key feature that regulates availability of a calcium channel to open, is thought to involve a physical occlusion of the channel pore by a cytoplasmic gating particle. This inactivation gate appears to be formed at least in part by the cytoplasmic domain I-II linker region. However, other regions of the channel, in particular the S6 helices, are also important (reviewed in Ref. 267), perhaps by forming a docking site for the inactivation gate (268). The COOH terminus region of the 1-subunit contains the key loci responsible for calcium-dependent inactivation, a process that is observed only when calcium is used as the charge carrier. Originally thought to occur only with L-type channels, more recent evidence indicates that all types of high voltage-activated channels are subject to this type of regulation by calcium ions. Mechanistically, this process involves a dynamic interaction of the calcium binding protein calmodulin with the COOH-terminal region of the 1-subunit (158, 170, 218, 320).
The cytoplasmic linker regions of various types of calcium channel 1-subunits form key interaction sites for regulatory proteins and may be substrates for phosphorylation events. For example, the I-II linker regions of Cav2.1 and Cav2.2 subunits interact with G protein -subunits (for review see Refs. 70, 74, 315); the II-III linker regions of these two channels interact with a number of synaptic proteins (for review, see Refs. 40, 259). The domain II-III linker region of Cav3.2 interacts with G2-subunits (306) and is a substrate for calmodulin-dependent protein kinase phosphorylation (299). These are but a few examples, as the list of calcium channel interacting proteins is too extensive to comprehensively review here. Nonetheless, in the context of epilepsy-associated genetic mutations, it is important to consider that their physiological effects may manifest themselves by interfering with calcium channel regulatory mechanisms, without necessarily causing alterations in the biophysical properties of the channels per se.
D. Ancillary Subunits of Calcium Channels
While calcium channel 1-subunit is sufficient to form functional channels, the association of HVA channel 1-subunits with ancillary - (73), 2-- (5, 35, 147), and -subunits (18) is known to result in altered functional properties and/or increased plasma membrane expression.
The 2--subunit is translated as a single gene product, and then posttranslationally cleaved into a membrane-spanning -peptide (27 kDa) and extracellular 2-peptide (143 kDa) (60), which are subsequently relinked via disulfide bonds. Expression studies have shown that the 2--protein alters current kinetics and current densities when coexpressed with HVA 1-subunits, although to different degrees with different channels (147, 310). The 2--subunit is the only known calcium channel ancillary subunit to interact with a clinically active drug compound, in that its association with gabapentin mediates analgesia (251). To date, four genes encoding for different 2--proteins (2-1, 2-2, 2-3, 2-4) have been identified, with several potential additional splice variants (146).
Four different types of -subunits (1 through 4), along with various splice variants (reviewed in Refs. 73, 232), have been identified and characterized. Unlike 2- proteins, -subunits appear to be exclusively cytosolic in nature, with the exception of 2a, which can become palmitoylated and thus membrane anchored (90, 228). The -subunit core resembles membrane-associated guanylate kinase homologs with conserved interacting SH3 and guanylate kinase (GK) domains (275). Residues in the GK domain participate in the formation of a hydrophobic groove that is involved in the high-affinity binding to a conserved region within the domain I-II linker region of HVA calcium channels, termed alpha interaction domain (AID) (47, 291). Recently published crystal structure data have revealed that binding of the -subunit to the channel is critically dependent on a functional association of the SH3 and GK regions (47, 213, 291), which is stabilized by the beta interaction domain, a short amino acid stretch that was originally thought to directly interact with the calcium channel AID region (291). The functional consequences of -subunit coexpression include increased plasma membrane expression of the 1-subunit (17, 48, 226) as well as altered channel kinetics (90, 310) (reviewed in Ref. 5). Consistent with an important role in calcium channel function, knockout of individual -subunit genes results in severe physiological consequences (see Table 3).
Eight different types of -subunits have been identified (1 through 8) (5). The -subunits are comprised of four transmembrane domains with intracellular NH2 and COOH termini (Fig. 2), but the mutual sites of interaction with the 1-subunit remain unknown. While it has been observed that some of the -subunits have the propensity to alter the functional characteristics of HVA calcium channels (238) (reviewed in Ref. 18), the precise action of these subunits on HVA calcium channels remains to be completely understood, and there is evidence that these subunits can interact with other membrane proteins such as AMPA receptors (45).
Considering the important roles of these subunits in regulating calcium channel function, one may perhaps expect that naturally occurring mutations in calcium channel subunit genes may have the propensity to alter normal physiological responses in animals and humans. As we will outline below, this does indeed occur within the context of idiopathic generalized epilepsies.
|
III. VOLTAGE-GATED CALCIUM CHANNELS AND ANCILLARY SUBUNITS IN IDIOPATHIC GENERALIZED EPILEPSY |
|---|
|
TopPreviousNextReferences |
|---|
T-type channels mediate a spectrum of physiological roles including pacemaker activity and various forms of physiological and pathophysiological neuronal oscillations (99, 217). Moreover, it was recently demonstrated that T-type channel activity can result in calcium-induced calcium release in neurons of the paraventricular nucleus of the thalamus and other midline neurons associated with the thalamocortical system (233). [Note that calcium-induced calcium release is known to occur in thalamocortical neurons but it does not involve the action of T-type channels (29).] This novel role for T-type channels in the thalamocortical system putatively lends itself to numerous calcium-dependent signaling pathways that extend the role of these channels beyond their biophysical attributes and into complex processes such as synaptic plasticity (237).
T-type channels display several unique biophysical features compared with HVA channels. They activate and inactivate near the resting membrane potential of neurons (approximately –60 mV), display more rapid inactivation kinetics, and deactivate more slowly to produce pronounced tail currents (30). There is also an increased overlap in the voltage dependences of activation and inactivation, which gives rise to a phenomenon termed the "window current." At membrane voltages where the window current is operational, a small fraction of T-type channels never fully inactivates and can be rapidly recruited for calcium influx upon depolarization. Interactions between the window current and the K+ leak current in thalamic (reticular and thalamocortical) and possibly cortical neurons can result in membrane bistability (57). This T-type-mediated potential can interact with other active currents (e.g., Ih) to modulate neuronal output between nonoscillatory and oscillatory modes that have different physiological correlates such as the slow (<1 Hz) sleep rhythm (57, 124). In response to a membrane hyperpolarization, a large fraction of T-type channels is recovered from the inactivated state, thus priming them for opening events. The ensuing calcium entry is thought to mediate a low-threshold calcium potential, a transient membrane depolarization that is sufficiently large to trigger a succession of sodium spikes (62, 157, 188, 245, 314). This feature is commonly referred to as "rebound bursting" and has been shown to occur in various neuronal subtypes including thalamocortical relay neurons, thalamic reticular neurons (54, 69, 126, 174), and a subpopulation of neocortical cells (61).
2. T-type calcium channel distribution
It is important to note that the precise biophysical characteristics of T-type calcium channels in relation to their physiological roles vary with Cav3 channel subtype and can be dramatically affected by alternate splicing of a given T-type channel gene (203). Their unique gating kinetics in addition to their specific regional distribution allows for these channels to be used by different neuronal subtypes to generate a variety of network dynamics. The exact distribution and protein expression levels of T-type calcium channels in the brain are not well understood, with most of the current knowledge having been derived from in situ hybridization studies in rat brain slices (55, 138, 276). Although T-type channel mRNA has been detected across all brain regions including the cerebellum, we focus predominantly on the major brain structures thought to be involved in spike-wave seizures, i.e., the thalamus and neocortex. All three T-type isoforms are expressed at relatively high levels in the hippocampus (276), with Cav3.1 being the dominantly expressed subtype in thalamocortical neurons (276). In contrast, Cav3.2 and Cav3.3 appear to be expressed more prominently in the thalamic reticular nucleus (276). Cells in this nucleus are primarily GABAergic interneurons that play a key role in synchronizing thalamic outputs onto thalamocortical neurons that then project to the cortex (262). Diffuse mRNA levels have been detected for Cav3.1 and Cav3.3 in most cortical areas (276). Transcript levels of Cav3.2 in the cortex typically occur at lower levels, except in layer V cortical pyramidal neurons (276). It should be noted, however, that it is not clear whether presence of mRNA correlates well with protein expression levels in the plasma membrane, and what particular splice isoform of the channel may be present (105).
In most types of neurons, the specific subcellular distribution of T-type channels has not yet been identified by immunocytochemical means. However, concordant evidence from numerous electrophysiological and functional imaging studies suggests that they are located both on and near the soma (136), and generally at more distal dendritic sites (129, 137, 139, 182, 188, 200). Moreover, a recent study using electrophysiological and pharmacological investigation of reticular cells in thalamic brain slices indicates the presence of a slowly inactivating T-type current in the dendrites and a fast inactivating current at the soma (133). Pharmacological manipulations have suggested that the fast inactivating current is likely to be carried by Cav3.2 channels, whereas the slow T-type current may be mediated by Cav3.3 channels. These results are supported by data from in situ hybridization studies for reticular neurons where mRNA expression of both isoforms has been detected (276). The subcellular distribution (e.g., soma vs. dendrites) is likely subject to further heterogeneity when considering the different T-type channel isoforms, splice variants, and developmental changes in the lifetime of the organism. For example, previous reports in reticular thalamic neurons have reported differences in the rates of inactivation of T-type currents in intact slices (66) (slow) compared with acutely dissociated neurons (126) (fast).
3. T-type channels and the thalamocortical network
The thalamocortical circuit is the primary link between peripheral sensory systems and the cerebral cortex. This circuitry is also one of the most studied in the context of neurophysiological rhythm generation and encompasses structures responsible for the regulation of brain states such as arousal and slow-wave sleep, a hallmark thalamocortical oscillation (263). From a simplistic anatomical perspective, this circuit consists of a network of reticular, thalamocortical (also referred to as relay), and neocortical neurons. Cortical neurons directly innervate reticular and thalamocortical neurons, whereas the reticular neurons provide GABAergic projections onto each other and onto thalamocortical neurons, which in turn synapse onto neocortical neurons (Fig. 3). Indeed, although the thalamus receives many sensory inputs, the primary source of excitatory synapses onto it comes from the cortex (86, 87, 172, 173), which exemplifies the influence of neocortical activity on thalamic information processing. Both neocortical and thalamocortical cells have excitatory projections back onto reticular neurons, and the activity of the circuit is further regulated via thalamic (local circuit) and neocortical interneurons (189, 249). The intraconnectivity between reticular neurons is believed to be a form of lateral inhibition (286) and central to the role of this local network in modulating overall thalamic outputs to cortical areas during both physiological and seizure activity (100, 255).
|
The low-threshold calcium potential-induced bursts of action potentials occur in a subpopulation of reticular neurons and are manifested as tonic firing with burstlike modulation due to membrane bistability (100). The GABAergic activity of reticular neurons (involving both GABAA and GABAB) results in hyperpolarization and subsequent low-threshold calcium potential-mediated rebound bursting in thalamocortical neurons, which faithfully track the bursts in the reticular network and manifest themselves as sleep spindles (263). There is some evidence from in vivo studies that burst-mode firing in thalamic neurons can occur during wakefulness (109, 110); however, this is not a common occurrence, and this interpretation may be complicated by an intermediate state of brain activity such as drowsiness (264).
Absence-type seizures occur preferentially during drowsiness or slow-wave sleep, which highlights the involvement of common synchronizing elements (such as the reticular network) underlying certain sleep and seizure states. However, unlike the state when sleep spindles are generated (101), the presence and interaction with the cortex is critical for the generation of SWDs (266). During cortically generated SWDs the GABAergic reticular neurons faithfully follow the cortical bursting activity and are synchronized with the activity recorded in the cortex (Fig. 4). In contrast, thalamocortical neurons undergo a sustained hyperpolarization in response to phasic inhibitory postsynaptic potentials (IPSPs), which are however incapable of recovering a sufficiently large fraction of T-type channels. Consequently, thalamocortical neurons do not exhibit rebound bursts during the epoch when SWDs are observed in the cortex (265) (Fig. 4). Reticular neurons are thus driven by the activity in the cortex, which leads to the inhibition of thalamocortical neurons, and prevents the feedback to cortical areas. Therefore, in one possible scenario, increased T-type channel (i.e., Cav3.2 and Cav3.3) activity could result in increased burst-mode firing in thalamic reticular neurons. The persistent activity of reticular neurons during SWDs causes increased membrane conductance in thalamocortical neurons in the form of steady inhibition, which may perhaps explain the unconsciousness during absence seizures caused by inhibition of synaptic transmission of signals from the outside world (263). It should be noted that there are a large number of modeling studies in which underlying ionic currents and network dynamics are explored in the context of both physiological and epileptiform thalamocortical oscillations. Although review of these works is beyond the scope of this manuscript, a concise review by Destexhe and Sejnowski (68) is available.
|
Animal studies have provided insights as to whether T-type expression is altered via epileptic activity, or whether increased T-type expression is a requirement for the development of seizure activity. For example, the GAERS rat exhibits 7- to 11-Hz SWDs, usually after 30 days of life. In this rat model of absence epilepsy, an increase in T-type currents in reticular neurons has been reported after the second postnatal week (284). This increase in T-type currents is putatively mediated by elevated Cav3.2 expression in reticular neurons, which as the animal develops to exhibit absencelike seizures, is also accompanied by elevated expression of Cav3.1 in relay neurons (277). This suggests that an increase in T-type channel expression can precede the development of seizures, perhaps by altering network dynamics via mechanisms that affect potentiation. In support of this notion, a modeling study employing a strictly thalamic network has demonstrated differential effects on network activity in response to an augmented T-type conductance in reticular neurons (279). Although rebound spiking number in individual reticular neurons was relatively unchanged, the increase in T-type conductance resulted in increased network synchrony by introducing a phase-lag between reticular and thalamocortical firing. It should be noted that a similar effect on synchrony was observed for increased calcium-activated potassium conductance in the model. Nonetheless, a degree of caution is warranted when attempting to interpret these results in relation to in vivo recordings that take place in the context of larger and more complexly connected networks. Presently, a precise causal connection between increased T-type channel activity and subsequent development of seizures remains to be established. It is conceivable that developmental causes involving either modulation of the channels, their redistribution with other isoforms, and alternate splicing may be contributing factors. Indeed, such developmental effects occur in the heart where Cav3.1 and Cav3.2 undergo differential developmental expression (208). Such alterations resulting in an epileptic phenotype represent gradual neurophysiological changes over time. In converse to these more slowly developing processes of epileptogenesis, it has been shown that even a single episode of status epilepticus in rat hippocampal brain slices can result in a selective increase in T-type channel activity, indicating that epileptic seizures per se may have the propensity to rapidly alter T-type currents (271), thus potentially lowering the threshold for subsequent seizure events.
Recent in vivo studies involving T-type (Cav3.1) knock-out (KO) mice have provided additional insights into the role of T-type channels in the generation of SWDs and absencelike seizure episodes (144). Ablation of the Cav3.1 gene in mice abolishes rebound spiking in dissociated adult thalamocortical neurons but does not alter their ability to fire tonically. Deep thalamic recordings from Cav3.1 KO mice also revealed a lack of synchronized activity. In vivo recordings from the cortical surface in these mice demonstrated a resistance to baclofen-induced 3- to 5-Hz SWDs that could be induced in control animals. This resistance could be due to a loss of rebound bursting in thalamocortical neurons, which are known to express high levels of Cav3.1 channels and to receive strong GABAergic inputs. Intriguingly, these mice are not resistant to SWDs induced by bicuculline, and tonic-clonic seizures were inducible in both KO and control animals with 4-aminopyridine injection. A possible explanation of why these mice experience bicuculline-induced seizures may be due to cortical involvement. Indeed, previous work has shown that the isolated cortex is able to generate bicuculline-induced SWDs, suggesting that the cortex can act as the seizure-generating zone (266). An alternative explanation for lack of protection against seizures in some models versus others may involve the reticular neurons that are known to predominantly express Cav3.2 and Cav3.3 T-type channels rather than Cav3.1. Therefore, it is conceivable that other T-type calcium channel isoforms (for example, Cav3.2) may be involved in the generation of hypersynchronous activity in some models of epilepsy without requiring the action of Cav3.1 channels in thalamocortical neurons. The findings obtained with Cav3.1 KO mice also indicate that full-blown convulsive seizures may recruit different mechanistic pathways. Moreover, consistent with the functional link between T-types and intrathalamic rhythm generation, Cav3.1 KO mice show altered sleep architecture, with markedly diminished thalamic delta (1–4 Hz) waves and sleep spindles (7–14 Hz) (159). Intriguingly, the slow (<1 Hz) rhythms that can be sustained by the cortex remained relatively intact in KO animals.
More recently, it has been demonstrated that Cav3.1 KO rescues the epileptic phenotypes seen in a number of murine models of absence seizures, including Cav2.1 knockout mice, which (as we discuss in detail in sect. IIIB1) display severe absence seizures (256). Thalamocortical neurons isolated from Cav2.1 KO mice were shown to exhibit an 50% increase in T-type currents (predominantly due to Cav3.1). In contrast, Cav2.1–/–/Cav3.1+/– mice exhibited a 25% reduction in T-type currents, yet they continued to exhibit SWDs with no changes in seizure frequency or duration. Thalamic mRNA transcript levels for Cav3.1 were not different between Cav2.1+/+ and Cav2.1–/– mice. These findings suggest that, under certain conditions, even reduced levels of T-type channel activity are capable of sustaining SWDs. Overall, these results indicate that complete KO of Cav3.1 channels can play a protective role against SWDs in these genetic models of absence epilepsy, as well as in a subset of pharmacological seizure models (Fig. 5).
|
Ion channel defects are considered to be one of the primary etiological causes of idiopathic generalized epilepsy (244). T-type channels have always been likely candidates due to their eminent presence in cortical and thalamic structures and their established physiological role in modulating neuronal firing. Moreover, clinically active antiepileptic drugs have been associated with T-type calcium channel inhibition (see below). However, although long suspected, a direct link involving T-type channels and the generalized spike-wave epilepsies in humans was only recently established. A number of missense mutations have now been identified in the Cav3.2 calcium channel gene in patients diagnosed with childhood absence epilepsy and other forms of idiopathic generalized epilepsy (Fig. 6). The first genetic study involved 118 patients with childhood absence epilepsy, and point mutations were detected in 14 of these patients, but not in 230 control individuals (46). Intriguingly, none of the affected individuals had a family history of epilepsy, but carriers inherited a mutant copy of the gene in a heterozygous manner from one parent. A large number of polymorphisms were also reported that were identified in both childhood absence epilepsy and control groups. Of the identified 12 mutations, only two were found in more than one affected individual. A second study investigated a heterogeneous population of patients with idiopathic generalized epilepsy (including childhood absence epilepsy, juvenile myoclonic epilepsy, and febrile convulsions) and identified three additional missense mutations and one nonsense mutation that occurred in 9 of 192 individuals (118). None of these new mutations segregated with a specific epilepsy phenotype, and their presence was not associated with a single subtype of idiopathic generalized epilepsy. It is important to note that every single one of the reported Cav3.2 mutations could also be found in seizure-free individuals.
|
It should be noted that alterations in biophysical properties of mutant channels are not expected to be the sole mechanism for the generation of pathophysiology. It is conceivable that processes such as neuronal development, targeting of channels to appropriate subcellular compartments, and/or cumulative effects from multiple mutations can all contribute to the etiology of idiopathic generalized epilepsies. Moreover, as outlined earlier, it is well known that many intracellular proteins interact with voltage-gated calcium channels and perhaps a number of these "biophysically silent" mutations might, given their localization on intracellular linkers, disrupt important intracellular signaling pathways that bring about, or contribute to, the epileptic phenotype (see also NOTE ADDED IN PROOF). Ultimately, it may prove necessary to perform conditional and region-specific knockin animal studies (both in isolation and combinations thereof) to elucidate their exact functional role in seizure genesis. From a clinical point of view, it appears as if mutant channels with large biophysical changes compared with wild-type channels account for only a small fraction of affected individuals. This is supported by the low incidence of mutations that segregate with idiopathic generalized epilepsy phenotypes (34, 278). Nonetheless, genetically identified mutations in patients and investigation of their function have served to further implicate T-type channels as important players in the idiopathic generalized epilepsies.
Collectively, these findings support the notion that idiopathic generalized epilepsies comprise complex forms of epilepsy where numerous susceptibility alleles can appear and disappear in an individual’s genome through factors such as meiotic reshuffling and chance events. Thus these alleles may not segregate in a Mendelian manner and in isolation do not appear to cause a sufficiently large perturbation to the functioning of brain networks to results in the disease phenotype. Instead, they could give rise to a genetic susceptibility by which their effects can combine with other alleles, perhaps involving the same or other proteins, to cause the epileptic condition in affected individuals (201). However, it is possible that future genetic linkage studies may identify calcium channel mutations that clearly segregate, in a Mendelian manner, with an epileptic phenotype.
B. P/Q-Type Channel Defects and Spike-Wave Seizure Disorders
Central to the mechanisms of spindle and SWD generation are oscillatory rhythms, specifically in the thalamic reticular network (99), which along with bursting activity in areas of the cortex affect the entire thalamocortical circuitry and modulate the firing of thalamocortical neurons (263). Although electrical synapses have recently been implicated in synchronizing the activities of reticular neurons (98, 156, 175), chemical synaptic transmission remains a primary mode of synchronizing the neuronal ensembles required for the generation of SWDs in both the thalamus and cortex. Because Cav2.1 (P/Q-type) calcium channels are key mediators of synaptic transmission in most central and peripheral neurons, alterations in Cav2.1 channel function therefore have the propensity to affect both cellular and network behavior.
1. Cav2.1 channels and murine models of absence epilepsy
The first evidence implicating Cav2.1 channels in the generation of spike-wave seizures came from several mouse strains that showed absence-like seizure activity. The tottering (tg) mouse was originally identified based on observations of cerebellar ataxia and intermittent paroxysmal dyskinesis (211). Subsequent examinations revealed the presence of EEG abnormalities that corresponded to absencelike seizures with SWDs in the range of 5–7 Hz (94, 211). Electrophysiological recordings have revealed that CA3 hippocampal pyramidal neurons in tg mice are prone to increased burst firing caused by paroxysmal depolarizing shifts when exposed to a high extracellular K+ model of in vitro seizures, consistent with hyperexcitability (114, 115). The leaner (tgla) mice display cortical spike-and-wave discharges that also resemble absence seizures. These mice are reported to be severely ataxic and often have a short survival postweaning (94, 177). Finally, the Rocker mice show spontaneous bilateral SWDs in the 6- to 7-Hz range while awake at a frequency of about one episode per minute, and which are always accompanied by behavioral arrest (321). These three mouse genotypes and their seizure disorders are recessively inherited and characterized by mild to severe ataxia and, in the case of tgla, significant loss of cerebellar Purkinje and granular neurons (119).
All three mouse lines show defects in the gene encoding Cav2.1 channels (11) (Fig. 6). In tg mice, a proline residue normally found in the domain II S5-S6 region of Cav2.1 is replaced by leucine (78, 94). This amino acid substitution reportedly results in decreased levels of P/Q-type current levels in native mouse neurons, as well as in transient expression studies (293), whereas the gating characteristics of the mutant channel do not appear to be significantly altered. Given that the mutation is located near the pore region of the channel, this decrease in current activity could perhaps be due to reduced single-channel amplitude, although this has not been confirmed experimentally. The reduction of P/Q-type channel activity in tg mice is paralleled by a dysfunction in neurotransmitter release in neocortical neurons (7) and a switch to N-type channel-mediated synaptic transmission (227). Moreover, this aberrant P/Q-type channel function may also account for reduced evoked excitatory synaptic potentials evoked in ventrobasal thalamic neurons (33).
The Cav2.1 calcium channel gene of tgla mice contains a nucleotide substitution in the COOH-terminal region that results in its premature truncation (78, 94). It has been reported that the tgla mutation causes altered P/Q-type channel currents and, like the tg mutation, reduces neurotransmitter release at neocortical synapses (7). It is unlikely that this mutation would affect single-channel conductance, suggesting that the reduced whole cell currents may either be due to a reduced probability of channel opening, or perhaps due to less effective targeting of the channel to the plasma membrane (i.e., reduced channel numbers). The Rocker mutation results in the replacement of a lysine residue (T1310K) in the domain III S5-S6 region with threonine (321) (Fig. 6). Its consequences on channel function in neurons or in transient expression systems remain to be determined, although the location near the pore site may again suggest possible effects on ion permeation. The common theme in the genetic absence models of tg and tgla mice appears to be a reduction in P/Q-type channel-mediated calcium entry, and hence synaptic release. This would be consistent with findings showing that complete genetic ablation of P/Q-type channels in mice results in absence seizures with behavioral arrests (256). However, it is important to note that the absence phenotype in these animal models does not occur in isolation, but rather is accompanied by other neurophysiological defects (i.e., ataxia, cerebellar atrophy), and this complicates our ability to link altered P/Q-type channel activity to the occurrence of seizures (see also sect. v).
2. Cav2.1 channelopathies in humans
In humans, a number of mutations in P/Q-type calcium channels have been associated with conditions such as episodic ataxia type 2 (64, 65, 97, 108, 131, 214, 246, 313) and familial hemiplegic migraine (214; reviewed in Ref. 220). In a few instances, patients carrying these mutations appear to exhibit absence seizures in addition to their ataxic phenotype. For example, a truncation mutation in the COOH-terminal region of Cav2.1 has been identified in a juvenile patient diagnosed with episodic ataxia type 2 and afflicted with childhood episodes of absence epilepsy and primary generalized seizures (134). This mutation results in a nonfunctional channel (Fig. 6), which in turn promotes a dominant-negative inhibition of wild-type channels. The same group of investigators recently reported on a family in which five patients exhibit absence epilepsy in combination with cerebellar ataxia (127). A novel point mutation in domain I-S2 region of the Cav2.1 calcium channel was identified, shown to segregate with the epileptic/ataxic phenotype, and to result in impairment of channel function. The significance of this study is the apparent association between absence seizures and reduced P/Q-type channel function, which is again consistent with findings in tg and tgla mice. However, it is important to point out that the occurrence of absence seizures in episodic ataxia type 2 patients with P/Q-type channel mutations appears to be rare. Similarly, although familial hemiplegic migraine mutations in P/Q-type channels have been linked with the occurrence of seizures in several case studies (14, 81, 148), these seizures were not classified as absence. Hence, the majority of P/Q-type channel mutations identified in humans, unlike in the rodent counterparts, do not seem to give rise to absence epilepsy.
Considering that loss of P/Q-type channel activity can contribute to the development of absence seizures, one may perhaps speculate that the mutations that give rise to the familial hemiplegic migraine might not result in reduced P/Q-type currents. The functional effects of a number of the familial hemiplegic migraine mutations have been examined following transient expression in systems such as Xenopus oocytes (150, 151), HEK293 cells (111, 283), cultured cerebellar granule neurons (283), and cultured hippocampal neurons (36); however, no clear-cut trend has emerged as to whether these mutations produce gains or loss of P/Q-type function. Most recently, the direct functional consequences of the four original familial hemiplegic migraine mutations (214) on excitatory (36) and inhibitory (37) synaptic transmission have been investigated. In the case of excitatory synaptic transmission, it was observed that all four mutant channels resulted in reduced current densities and diminished current influx for supporting synaptic transmission when compared with constituted wild-type channels in Cav2.1 KO cultured hippocampal neurons (36, 37). In the case of inhibitory synaptic transmission, expression of these mutant channels in inhibitory neurons cultured from Cav2.1 KO neurons reduced the contribution of these channels to supporting postsynaptic GABAergic currents compared with wild-type channels (37). The reduction in P/Q-type channel activity contrasts with the gain of channel function that is observed when certain familial hemiplegic migraine mutations were introduced into a mouse background (289). Given these conflicting results, it remains difficult to say whether the lack of absence seizures seen in familial hemiplegic migraine patients is related to the possibility that P/Q-type channel activity is increased, rather than the type of decrease observed in the case of most episodic ataxia type 2 mutations and in mouse genetic models of absence epilepsy (Fig. 6).
C. Involvement of Ancillary Subunits of Voltage-Gated Calcium Channels in Seizure Disorders
Ancillary calcium channel subunits are important regulators of HVA calcium channel function. Murine and/or human mutations associated with seizure activity have been identified in all three classes of ancillary subunits (Fig. 6). A frame-shift mutation resulting in a functional knockout of the calcium channel 4-subunit gives rise to the lethargic (lh) mouse phenotype, which is known to exhibit absence seizures and ataxia (31). In thalamic neurons isolated from these mice, excitatory, but not inhibitory, neurotransmitter release is reduced similar to what has been observed with tg mice (33). In humans, both missense and truncation mutations in the 4-subunit have been found in idiopathic generalized epilepsy patients (88). Considering that the 4-subunit is the primary subtype associated with P/Q-type channels, it is possible that these mutations may mediate their physiological effects by altering P/Q-type calcium channel function or targeting; however, since other types of calcium channel 1-subunits can also associate with 4, such a link is not equivocal. There may also be precedent for changes in calcium channel function via altered -subunit expression patterns in (focal) temporal lobe epilepsy as has been shown in a single study (171).
To our knowledge, mutations in either - or 2--subunits have so far not been linked to epilepsy in humans; however, there are several mouse phenotypes associated with these subunits. Two different mutations in the calcium channel 2-2 subunit (CACNA2D2 gene) result in loss of the full-length proteins giving rise to the ducky mouse, with the two identified forms being designated as du and du2J. Both mouse strains are characterized by behavioral arrest, bihemispheric spike-wave seizures with a frequency of 5–7 Hz, and ataxia and paroxysmal dyskinesia (
